She is a Tree of Life for Those Who Grasp Her: Rethinking Wisdom and Torah. Part 2: Wisdom, Torah, and Politics—A Political Reading of the Hezekian Collection

This post is part 2 of a series. See also parts 1 (Introduction), 3 (The Character of Moses), 4 (A Wise Torah), and 5 (Toward an Ethics of Reading).

The collection of aphorisms in Proverbs 25–29 begins with a header that identifies it as a product of the state: “These, too, are the sayings of Solomon, which the men of Hezekiah, king of Judah, transmitted” (25:1). This and other headers that structure the book of Proverbs are paratexts that frame the various collections in the book as we now have it and shape how we read it. At least as far as attribution to Solomon is concerned, these are late, pseudepigraphical additions, akin to the attribution of various psalms to David.1 They are widely thought to lend “authority, maybe even orthodoxy” to the collection by associating it with a founder figure, but they also serve literary purposes, knitting together corpuses in relatively late stages of development and fleshing out the biographies of these key biblical figures.2

The attribution to the men of Hezekiah is also taken by some as pseudepigraphical, an effort to frame him as a second Solomon. Hezekiah was the first king since Solomon to rule over a united kingdom—in his case, what was left of it—and both are depicted as “successful” (שׂכ״ל, hiphil), Hezekiah in his efforts to strengthen the kingdom of Judah in the face of Assyrian threat (2 Kings 18:7), and Solomon in David’s charge that he will meet with success if he heeds God’s instruction as it is written in the “torah of Moses” (1 Kings 2:3).3 The nouns that relate to this verb (שׂכל and משׂכיל) are common in the book of Proverbs, where they refer to a person who possesses good sense, or, as Fox puts it, “discernment or prudence, the ability to understand practical matters and interpersonal relations and make beneficial decisions.”4 It stands to reason that this would be a desirable trait in a king.

Yet there are good reasons to take the Hezekian attribution of this collection as “first-rate evidence” that it was produced “at Hezekiah’s court and under his patronage.”5 It does not do the same literary work as the Solomonic attribution, because Hezekiah is not a founder figure like David, Solomon, or Moses. In fact, the attribution is to the men of Hezekiah, not Hezekiah himself, as one would expect if pseudepigraphical founder discourse were at work here. In this sense, Proverbs 25:1 is not like Isaiah 38:9, which places the following poem in the mouth of Hezekiah upon rising from his sickbed. That text is akin to the attribution of various psalms to David in that it fleshes out an emotional landscape for his character; it lets us not just read about Hezekiah’s deeds but also understand his trust in Yahweh, which plays a key role in the events of his reign.6 The statement that scribes in Hezekiah’s employ transmitted a collection of sayings accomplishes no such goal. I am therefore inclined to agree with those who think that the collection is best understood as authentically Hezekian, and to think that its superscript was reframed to attribute it to Solomon and cast Hezekiah’s scribes as tradents rather than authors.7

Although such collections draw on the trope of parent-child teaching, which is grounded in real social practice, they do not seem to have been produced for the education of children. They are literary texts with close Egyptian analogues, often understood as manuals used to train people for royal service and socialize them into court culture.8 The Hezekian collection constitutes instruction of this sort, and self-consciously so, as several verses refer to torah (תורה). Abandoning it leads to radically warped judgment, such that one would praise a wicked person, unable to discern who and what is praiseworthy. Turning a deaf ear to it results in prayer so misdirected that it would constitute an abomination (Proverbs 28:4, 9). Embracing it is not only smart but will lead to happiness, perhaps akin to what the Greeks call eudaimonia, or well-being (28:7; 29:18). Given the Hebrew Bible in the form we now have it, it is tempting to take these references to torah here to mean the Torah, or some version of it, such as Deuteronomy, and understand it as a reference to the divinely revealed instruction there.9 Yet, as Fox notes, “[t]he content of torah is open-ended. It may refer to whatever is taught in the book of Proverbs, or in the present collection, or in instructions of this sort.”10 In none of these references does torah clearly refer to the “torah of Moses” that will make Solomon successful if he adheres to it. If they refer to any body of literature at all, it is most likely to be the very collection of sayings in which they appear.11 I propose that the Hezekian collection deployed this classic Egyptian genre in a creative way not only to teach bureaucrats how to behave at court but also to support Hezekiah’s statecraft.

This would not be the only time scribes in Hezekiah’s employ wrote literature to serve political ends. It has long been recognized that the account of Moses’s infancy is modeled on the Sargon birth legend, a work of fictional autobiography that linked the Assyrian king Sargon with the founder of the first empire in the region. I have argued elsewhere that this work informs not just the birth scene but the earliest version of the Moses story, which extends at least through the rock-water narrative in Exodus 17.12 It is structured around three acts of striking—the Egyptian, the Nile, and the rock—by which Moses extricates the Israelites from Egypt and ensures that they are able to survive on their own. Like its model, the Moses story is political allegory. Its protagonist (whose name means “[Water-]Drawer”) is the literary alter ego of Hezekiah, who had been an Assyrian ally until opportunities arose in 712 and again in 705 BCE to rebel, with the support of Egypt. This entanglement proved disastrous, and the story is about Hezekiah’s political reversal, as he left Egypt and struck the rock of Zion in order to bring water into Jerusalem and give Judah a chance of surviving Assyrian seige, which came in 701 BCE. The choice of genre depicts Hezekiah (Moses) as a model Assyrian king, a message surely designed to support his effort to revert to the pro-Assyrian stance that had characterized Judah’s foreign policy since Hezekiah’s father, Ahaz, refused to get involved in the Syro-Ephraimite rebellion. The literature is the politics.

Prior to the failure of Hezekiah’s Egyptian alliance, Judah was all in—or almost all in. The political partnership with and cultural attunement toward Egypt is reflected in Judean royal iconography during this period, which featured a winged snake, or uraeus, a long-standing symbol of kingship in Egypt. It appears on seals and ivory carvings, as well as in the form of a bronze snake, which may have been on public display until it was likely destroyed both to symbolize the end of the Egyptian alliance and to secure the valuable materials needed to pay tribute to Sennacherib in 701.13 Yet Isaiah opposed this Egyptian strategy, which he viewed as a violation of divine instruction, or “torah of Yahweh” (Isaiah 30:9). He attacked royal counselors for ignoring his message that God would intervene as they advised the king on foreign policy, relying on wisdom gleaned from other sources and their intellectual skill, and he insisted that his own torah be collected and written down, perhaps not unlike Hezekiah’s collection of sayings, as a witness of God’s faithfulness in a time of crisis and a warning of the consequences of failing to take into account the word of the LORD (8:16; 30:9–10). These instances of torah do not refer to the Pentateuch (or any version of it) any more than those in Hezekiah’s collection of sayings but are generally understood to refer to Isaiah’s own teaching.14

Yet Isaiah’s instruction comes from God. This could be an independent use of the word torah, but Isaiah may also have borrowed the term from the royal counselors “at least partly as a strategem for bringing his message into the royal council where vital decisions were to be made.”15 This would be consistent with his view that they are wise only in their own eyes, not necessarily because conventional wisdom is bad, but because they fail to recognize God as an important source of instruction and account for divine torah in their deliberations. This is a particularly egregious omission given ancient Near Eastern kingship ideology, where the deity who sponsors the king—in Hezekiah’s case, Yahweh—is an important (if not the most important) source of counsel.16

Might we understand the Hezekian collection in Proverbs 25–29 in this context? Leo Purdue notes that “it may not be coincidental that Hezekiah established a pro-Egyptian lobby at court that Isaiah opposed,” and Michael Fishbane wonders if the “men of Hezekiah” to whom this instructional literature is attributed might be the teachers of wisdom whom Isaiah mocked, “those who are wise in their own eyes” (Isaiah 5:21), whose “wisdom” will fail (ואבדה חכמת חכמיו, Isaiah 29:14).17 (It is tempting to read the verb אב״ד here as doublespeak, signifying the demise not only of their counsel but also of Judah itself, because of their unwise counsel.) What Perdue and Fishbane suggest is especially plausible if Hezekiah’s men were producing pro-Egyptian literature to complement their pro-Egyptian royal iconography, literature designed to enculturate Judeans in a distinctively Egyptian way in order to encourage support for this Egyptian alliance, perhaps in spite of Isaiah’s protestations.

This reading would seem to situate me squarely on the “school” side of the classic debate in scholarship on the book of Proverbs between, as Fox frames it, the “folk school” and the “‘school’ school.”18 The folk school emphasizes the familial context of most of the aphorisms in Proverbs and their broad applicability beyond a royal context, while the “school” school is inclined to see the collections as having been produced specifically in and for the court.19 Yet I am inclined to a less binary view. This literature serves the state not in any overt way, but by orienting cultural attitudes and shaping values that support strong relationships—in the court, to be sure, but also potentially across Judean society—in the interest of creating a functional community of people, able to be productive and ensure their individual and collective well-being. This instruction is packaged in a distinctively Egyptian framework, a nod to the cultural and political affiliation Hezekiah wished to nourish in order to protect Judah from the Assyrians. In effect, it takes existing culture and channels it in a political direction. It can do that job most successfully by drawing on wisdom that is already widely accepted as good common sense and building on it in ways that are broadly applicable and do not seem political.20

The framing, in Proverbs 25:2–7, clearly shapes ideas about the king and standards for behavior among his community of advisors.21 The first two proverbs tell us something about the relationship between king and deity (Proverbs 25:2–3).22 God does not tell the king directly how to manage state affairs; it is the king’s job to search out knowledge of a matter, which is implicit in the divinely created world around him and can be discerned through observation and critical reflection, and decide how to put it to work. His mind is as expansive as creation (“like the heavens in their height, like the earth in its depth”), so his subjects are to trust that he is well equipped for the task of searching, even if the logic behind his decisions seems inscrutable to them. This saying can certainly apply to any king at any time, but, in the context of a Hezekian collection, we would not be wrong to wonder whether it applies specifically to this king’s decision to pursue an alliance with Egypt, a decision that Isaiah—who characterized Egypt as a splintered reed that would puncture the hand of anyone who leaned on it (Isaiah 36:6)—was surely not the only person to oppose. If so, it may be read as an effort to discourage dissent, as it puts the king beyond question, giving him a godlike character vis-à-vis his subjects. Even if his policies do not make sense, we should trust that he knows what he is doing.

The rest of the royal frame for this collection likens creating community around the king to the process of purifying and refining silver into a valuable vessel (Proverbs 25:4). If his rule is to be a righteous one, wicked people, like dross, must be marginalized; they cannot be allowed to wield power and influence (25:5). Those who remain are to stay in their lane until they are invited out of it (25:6–7). As Fox notes, “this refers to any type of self-promotion and maneuvering to reach above one’s station.”23 The king and those in higher-ranking positions thus have the power to determine who gets to speak and when—in other words, to influence the kind of counsel that is even available to them as they navigate affairs of state. This need not squelch dissent, as a king may invite opposing perspectives in order to consider all the factors in a given matter and as many options as possible for handling it, and a wise king arguably would. But it does make things easy for a king who would prefer to sideline those who might not tell him what he wants to hear. Either way, court culture is shaped from the top down.

Once this initial framing sets the tone, the obviously royal aphorisms are scattered throughout the rest of the collection.24 We learn how to get things done, specifically that patience and gentle language is more effective at breaking down intransigent colleagues than show of force (Proverbs 25:15). We learn the dangers of listening to false counsel (29:12), and Fox’s reading again captures the idea well: “corruption quickly seeps downward and permeates the power heirarchy. If a ruler’s minions learn that falsehood is what gets the boss’s ear, that’s what they will give him.”25 We are warned that lack of understanding or corruption (or both) will lead to tyrrany (28:15–16).26 And the final chapter of the Hezekian collection connects us with ancient Near Eastern kingship ideology, as two of its aphorisms depict an ideal in which the king rules with justice that has its ultimate source in God (29:4, 26).27

There may be one other royal proverb, which counsels the shepherd to mind his flock “because wealth does not last forever, or a crown from generation to generation” (Proverbs 27:23–24). Reference to a crown, together with the common use of shepherd imagery to depict kings, suggests to some that this is a royal proverb, although others are skeptical, especially as it comes in a series of sayings about agricultural life. Fox, among the skeptics, understandably wonders why a message of impermanence would be promoted among the royal ranks.28 Yet this is another case where picturing this folk wisdom being made to do political work in a Hezekian context can help us make sense of the text, because Hezekiah’s reign was indeed in danger. The Assyrians had destroyed Samaria and absorbed the kingdom of Israel. Judah’s survival (and his own on the throne) depended on his ability to “mind well his flock and set his mind to his herds” lest “his wealth not last forever.” Alliance with Egypt was, at this point, his strategy for keeping Judah independent and ensuring the continuity of his reign. It proved to be a miscalculation in the end, but Hezekiah’s cunning and skill, evident in the Moses story, may have helped to keep him on the throne and ensure that Judah would remain independent for nearly two more centuries.

Featured image: Washington Allston, Jeremiah Dictating His Prophecy of the Destruction of Jerusalem to Baruch the Scribe (1820), Yale University Art Gallery, Wikimedia commons, public domain.

  1. See, e.g., R. B. Y. Scott, “Solomon and the Beginnings of Wisdom in Israel,” in Wisdom in Israel and in the Ancient Near East, Supplements to Vetus Testamentum 3 (Brill, 1955), 268–72 and Katharine J. Dell, “How Much Wisdom Literature Has Its Roots in the Pre-Exilic Period?,” in In Search of Pre-Exilic Israel: Proceedings of the Oxford Old Testament Seminar, ed. John Day, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 406 (T&T Clark International, 2004), 252–55. Some acknowledge the similarities with the Davidic headers in Psalms but think that the Solomonic headers could reflect a long-standing tradition of Solomon as a wise king; see, e.g., Brevard S. Childs, Introduction to the Old Testament as Scripture (Fortress, 1979), 551–52. ↩︎
  2. For the view that the headers lend authority to the collections (and the source of the quote), see Katharine J. Dell, “The King in the Wisdom Literature,” in King and Messiah in Israel and the Ancient Near East: Proceedings of the Old Testament Seminar, ed. John Day, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 270 (Sheffield Academic, 1998), 166. The dynamics of founder discourse are laid out in detail by Hindy Najman, Seconding Sinai: The Development of Mosaic Discourse in Second Temple Judaism, Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism 77 (Brill, 2003), and the more expansive array of creative literary purposes that might be served by such paratexts is explored by Eva Mroczek, The Literary Imagination in Jewish Antiquity (Oxford University Press, 2016) and, specifically for the Solomonic headers in Proverbs, Jacqueline Vayntrub, “Before Authorship: Solomon and Prov. 1:1,” Biblical Interpretation 26 (2018): 182–206. ↩︎
  3. The fullest argument that the attribution to Hezekiah is just as pseudepigraphical as the attribution to Solomon is offered by Michael Carasik, “Who Were the ‘Men of Hezekiah’ (Proverbs XXV 1)?,” Vetus Testamentum 44, no. 3 (1994): 289–300; see also Stuart Weeks, Early Israelite Wisdom (Clarendon, 1994), 46 and Leo G. Perdue, Wisdom Literature: A Theological History (Westminster John Knox, 2007), 44. ↩︎
  4. Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 1–9, Anchor Bible 18A (Doubleday, 2000), 36. ↩︎
  5. Scott, “Solomon and the Beginnings of Wisdom in Israel.”, 273. This view is followed by many, including Daniel C. Snell, Twice-Told Proverbs and the Composition of the Book of Proverbs (Eisenbrauns, 1993); Dell, “How Much?”, 255; William M. Schniedewind, How the Bible Became a Book (Cambridge University Press, 2004), 75–76; and Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 10–31, Anchor Yale Bible 18B (Yale University Press, 2009), 776. ↩︎
  6. While it is akin to the Davidic headers in Psalms, it is not necessarily as late. Isaiah 38:9 identifies the following text as a מכתב, whereas the Davidic headers in Psalms often have מכתם (Psalms 16; 56–60). Some commentators want to emend Isaiah 38:9 from מכתב to מכתם so the connection is explicit, but, as J. J. M. Roberts, First Isaiah: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Fortress, 2015), 480–81 notes, this emendation “rests on a very thin reed.” We should resist the urge to harmonize them, especially as Isaiah 38:9 is different from the Davidic paratexts in Psalms in a key respect: it is not a paratext but part of an extended narrative about Sennacherib’s invasion of Judah in 701 BCE, and the poem does more than flesh out an emotional life for Hezekiah. It also ties this image of his personal fate to the fate of Judah, as the ailing king is comparable to the sick nation in Isaiah 1:5, and his prayer that God will heal him parallels his prayer that God will save Judah in Isaiah 37:14–20; see Christopher R. Seitz, Isaiah 1–39, Interpretation (John Knox, 1989), 256–257 and Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Bible (Doubleday, 2000), 483–84. As John D. W. Watts, Isaiah 34–66, Word Biblical Commentary 25 (Word, 1987), 58 notes, this depiction of Hezekiah does much to “protect Hezekiah from blame for the 701 B.C. embarrassment.” In this sense, it complements the version of the Moses story modeled on the Sargon birth legend (for which see below) and would fit well in the late eighth century. ↩︎
  7. The superscript in Proverbs 25:1 may once have done nothing more than attribute the collection to Hezekiah’s men, much like the headers that attribute collections to individuals such as Agur, son of Yaqeh (30:1) or Lemuel, king of Massa (31:1). These are more typical of framing narratives in instructional literature, which ground the following speech in place and time, whereas the Solomonic attribution depends on outside literature connected with Solomon in order to make its framing statement about the speech in Proverbs; see Vayntrub, “Before Authorship.” The גם אלה (“these, too”) at the beginning of 25:1 depicts Hezekiah’s men adding to an existing corpus of Solomonic wisdom, which could be a description of what they actually did, or at least what the author thought they did; see, e.g., Katharine J. Dell, The Book of Proverbs in Social and Theological Context (Cambridge University Press, 2006), 82. But it could also be an effort to reframe an existing collection that initially had nothing to do with Solomon. JiSeong James Kwon and Matthias Brütsch, “Abschied von den Männern Hiskias. Proverbia 25–29 als späte Aramaisierende Komposition,” Biblica 104, no. 4 (2023): 520–23 note that “men of…” is not typically used of scribes and intellectuals in preexilic Hebrew, where they are called “servants” or “officials” and the expression “men of…” is limited to military personnel. This is part of their argument that the collection could not have been written by scribes in Hezekiah’s employ, but it could easily have been part of an effort to reframe the original attribution. There is no manuscript evidence or clear fracture in which to ground an argument that 25:1 was revised, so I offer this as a soft suggestion, one possible reading. That such edits could be made without leaving any trace is a lesson that Fox first taught me. It is reasonable to ask why the superscripts in Proverbs 30:1 or 31:1 were not similarly smoothed over, if these collections were in place when the material was attributed to Solomon. It is possible that they were missed, or, as noted, e.g., by Stuart Weeks, An Introduction to the Study of Wisdom Literature (T & T Clark, 2010), 24, they might also have been added later. ↩︎
  8. See, e.g., Hans-Jürgen Hermisson, Studien zur Israelitischen Spruchweisheit, Wissenschaftliche Monographien zum Alten und Neuen Testament (Neukirchener Verlag, 1968). On the literary character of instructional collections, see Michael V. Fox, “The Social Location of the Book of Proverbs,” in Texts, Temples, and Traditions: A Tribute to Menachem Haran, ed. Michael V. Fox et al. (Eisenbrauns, 1996), 229 and William M. Schniedewind, The Finger of the Scribe: How Scribes Learned to Write the Bible (Oxford University Press, 2019), 139. On the socialization, or enculturation, function of proverbs, see David M. Carr, Writing on the Tablet of the Heart: Origins of Scripture and Literature (Oxford University Press, 2005), 111–73, esp. 126. ↩︎
  9. There is much discussion in the commentaries about which instances of תורה in Proverbs refer to the Torah and which do not. The reasoning tends to be thin. For example, R. N. Whybray, Proverbs, New Century Bible Commentary (Eerdmans, 1994), 388 wants to see Proverbs 28:4 as a reference to divine law in some form because it focuses on how torah adherence (or lack thereof) affects one’s stance toward the wicked, but the Hezekian collection does the same thing. Leo Perdue, Proverbs, Interpretation (John Knox, 2000), 229–30 and William P. Brown, “The Law and the Sages: A Reexamination of Tôrâ in Proverbs,” in Constituting the Community: Studies on the Polity of Ancient Israel in Honor of S. Dean McBride Jr., ed. John T. Strong and Steven S. Tuell (Eisenbrauns, 2005), 269–72 both want to see a nascent wisdom-Torah link, particularly with Deuteronomy. Brown offers the most robust case, involving considerations such as shared vocabulary and familial context, but this does not establish direction of dependence between isolated verses, let alone that the author of the Hezekian collection drew from a legal corpus. ↩︎
  10. Fox, Proverbs 10–31, 823. See also Barnabas Lindars, “Torah in Deuteronomy,” in Words and Meanings: Essays Presented to David Winton Thomas, ed. Peter R. Ackroyd and Barnabas Lindars (Cambridge University Press, 1968), 122. ↩︎
  11. The notion that these references to torah refer to the Mosaic Torah is another arm of the argument put forward by Kwon and Brütsch, “Abschied” that the entire collection cannot have been written by Hezekiah’s scribes but dates to the Hellenistic period. Yet they overlook the fact that even within the Pentateuch itself the word often refers to individual instructions or groups of instruction. Short of specific references to characters or plots, such as the mention of Moses, Aaron, and Miriam together in Micah 6:4, or substantive quotations of specific texts, there is nothing solid on which to hang a case that the word torah refers to the entire Pentateuch (and even in these cases, it may or may not be the Pentateuch in the form we know it). The strongest element of their case that Proverbs 25–29 is postexilic is the presence of Aramaisms, which builds on the observation of Late Biblical Hebrew (LBH) features by Nili Samet, “The Lexical Enigma of מָנוֹן and the Problem of Dating the Hezekian Collection,” Zeitschrift für die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft128, no. 3 (2016): 419–32. The use of Aramaic does reach its peak during the Persian period, but the percentage of Aramaisms in the collection is very small, and Kwon and Brügsch themselves admit the possibility that they could be earlier, given the adoption of Aramaic by the Assyrian Empire. They bolster their claim for a Hellenistic date by pointing to features such as a tendency to embrace observation of nature, which fits a Hellenistic intellectual milieu, but dating texts on the basis of how they seem to fit in a history of ideas is notoriously slippery, as discussed in detail by Benjamin D. Sommer, “Dating Pentateuchal Texts and the Perils of Pseudo-Historicism,” in The Pentateuch: International Perspectives on Current Research, ed. Thomas B. Dozeman et al., Forschungen um Alten Testament 78 (Mohr Siebeck, 2011), 85–108. Aristotle may have systematized thought on the observation of nature, but there is a long history of natural observation in ancient Near Eastern culture, and it certainly influenced literature; see Jeffrey L. Cooley, Poetic Astronomy in the Ancient Near East: The Reflexes of Celestial Science in Ancient Mesopotamian, Ugaritic, and Israelite Narrative, History, Archaeology, and Culture of the Levant 5 (Eisenbrauns, 2013). A preexilic date for the collection cannot be ruled out on this basis. Samet offers a better-calibrated explanation of the late linguistic features as evidence that the collection was copied (with some linguistic updates) or revised during the postexilic period. This surely happened, given the growth of the book of Proverbs and the possibility that the header of this collection (25:1) was reframed. It would be worth looking at whether there is a discernible editorial strategy to such a revision, but this is beyond the scope of the present article. None of the verses within the collection that I discuss here are among those called out by Kwon and Brügsch or Samet as containing Aramaisms or features of LBH, so they are plausibly part of a preexilic version of the collection. ↩︎
  12. Angela Roskop Erisman, The Wilderness Narratives in the Hebrew Bible: Religion, Politics, and Biblical Interpretation (Cambridge University Press, 2025), 35–60. ↩︎
  13. For the seals and ivory carvings, see Othmar Keel and Christoph Uehlinger, Gods, Goddesses, and Images of God in Ancient Israel, trans. Thomas H. Trapp (Fortress, 1998), 251–53, 272–77. For the bronze snake, see Richard Lederman, “What Is the Biblical Flying Serpent?,” TheTorah.Com, n.d., and Richard Lederman, “Nehushtan, the Copper Serpent: Its Origins and Fate,” TheTorah.Com, n.d. The winged snake plays a role in several biblical texts, including Isaiah 14:29, where the winged seraph that sprouts from the stock of a snake is typically understood as a reference to Hezekiah, and 30:6, where it plays a role in Isaiah’s critique of Judah’s alliance with Egypt; see J. J. M. Roberts, “The Rod That Smote Philistia: Isaiah 14:28–32,” in Literature as Politics, Politics as Literature: Essays on the Ancient Near East in Honor of Peter Machinist, ed. David S. Vanderhooft and Abraham Winitzer (Eisenbrauns, 2013), 381–95. ↩︎
  14. See, e.g., John D. W. Watts, Isaiah 1–33, Word Biblical Commentary 24 (Word, 1985), 122 and Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39, 415–16. The first instance involves Ahaz’s refusal to join the anti-Assyrian coalition during the Syro-Ephraimite crisis, while the second comes as Hezekiah himself seeks alliance with Egypt after the death of Sargon in 705; for the political contexts, see Roberts, First Isaiah, 139, 387. On these tensions between Isaiah and Hezekiah’s counselors over foreign policy, see Joseph Blenkinsopp, Sage, Priest, Prophet: Religious and Intellectual Leadership in Ancient Israel, Library of Ancient Israel (Westminster John Knox, 1995), 32–33 and David M. Carr, The Formation of the Hebrew Bible: A New Reconstruction (Oxford University Press, 2011), 407. John Goldingay, “Proverbs and Isaiah 1–39,” in Reading Proverbs Intertextually, ed. Katharine Dell and Will Kynes, Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 629 (T & T Clark, 2019), 49–64 offers a clever reading that lets us imagine what their discussions might have been like. ↩︎
  15. Joseph Jensen, The Use of Tôrâ by Isaiah: His Debate with the Wisdom Tradition, Catholic Biblical Quarterly Monograph Series 3 (Catholic Biblical Association of America, 1973), quote 56; the term עצה, “plan” is borrowed as well as תורה. See also J. William Whedbee, Isaiah and Wisdom (Abingdon, 1971), 125–26, 144–45. ↩︎
  16. Jensen, Use, 58–62. ↩︎
  17. Perdue, Wisdom Literature, 46 and Michael Fishbane, Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (Clarendon, 1985), 33. ↩︎
  18. Fox, “Social Location,” 228. ↩︎
  19. Proponents of the folk school include Friedemann W. Golka, The Leopard’s Spots: Biblical and African Wisdom in Proverbs (T & T Clark, 1993)and Laurent Naré, Proverbes Salomoniens et Proverbes Mossi. Etude comparative à partir d’une nouvelle analyse de Pr 25–29, European University Studies, Series 23: Theology 283 (Peter Lang, 1986). Proponents of the “school” school include Bruce V. Malchow, “A Manual for Future Monarchs,” Catholic Biblical Quarterly 47, no. 2 (1985): 238–45 and Fox himself. R. N. Whybray, Wealth and Poverty in the Book of Proverbs, Journal for the Old Testament Supplement Series 99 (Sheffield Academic, 1990), 45–59 offers an extended discussion of why the existence of proverbs mentioning the king are not an argument for a court setting. He is correct that the mere mention of kings does not mean that the aphorisms serve the court, but this does not take into account the framing function of the royal proverbs in the Hezekian collection or the way they structure community around the king, both of which I discuss below. James Alfred Loader, Proverbs 1–9, Historical Commentary on the Old Testament (Peeters, 2014), 18 acknowledges the folk character of much of the content without eliminating the possibility that it was brought together in and for a court context, and I find this to be a useful approach. ↩︎
  20. Roland E. Murphy, “Wisdom—Theses and Hypotheses,” in Israelite Wisdom: Theological and Literary Essays in Honor of Samuel Terrien, ed. John G. Gammie et al. (Scholars Press, 1978) notes that it “is reasonable to correlate the court activity with the experiential wisdom of the people” (37). For the idea that the Hezekian collection drew on what once may have been personal or familial wisdom and transferred it to the realm of the political, see William P. Brown, “The Pedagogy of Proverbs 10:1–31:9,” in Character and Scripture: Moral Formation, Community, and Biblical Interpretation, ed. William P. Brown (Eerdmans, 2002), 171–75 and Brown, “Law and the Sages,” 270. Only the educated elite would have been able read a text like the collection in Proverbs 25–29, but culture spreads across a society through an array of different vectors, including imagery on objects such as stelae and seals and personal interactions (verbal communication, behavior modeling) as well as literature, and this is especially possible if it draws on existing wisdom. Fox allows for just this kind of work on the part of the scribes: “A scholar should be attentive to intelligent conversation and perceptive proverbs. It is a small step from here to recalling such things, along with written proverbs one has read, and embedding them in one’s own creations” (Fox, Proverbs 1–9, 10–11). On counsel that does not seem political and the importance of tapping into local knowledge in order to exercise the power to shape culture, see Corey Robin, Fear: The History of a Political Idea (Oxford University Press, 2004), 176 and 191–94 (on collaborators). ↩︎
  21. Raymond C. Van Leeuwen, Context and Meaning in Proverbs 25–27, Society of Biblical Literature Dissertation Series 96 (Scholars Press, 1988), 57–86 argues that the entirety of Proverbs 25 constitutes a wisdom poem; although this reading is generally rejected, some are willing to accept that verses 2–7 constitute a shorter poem about kingship that introduces the collection; see, e.g., R. N. Whybray, The Composition of the Book of Proverbs, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 168 (JSOT Press, 1994), 120–21. Fox, “Social Location,” 237 n. 40 notes that there are Egyptian analogues to such poems. ↩︎
  22. On the relationship to ancient Near Eastern kingship ideology, see Richard J. Clifford, Proverbs: A Commentary, Old Testament Library (Westminster John Knox, 1981), 222. ↩︎
  23. Fox, Proverbs 10–31, 780. ↩︎
  24. This is to be expected, as the introduction is what has the most effect on how we process the rest of a work; see Sara J. Milstein, Tracking the Master Scribe: Revision through Introduction in Biblical and Mesopotamian Literature (Oxford University Press, 2016). There are no grounds for taking Proverbs 25:2–7 as a revision to the collection, but Milstein’s comments on how introductions frame discourse are relevant even if the frame is native to a work. ↩︎
  25. Fox, Proverbs 10–31, 838. ↩︎
  26. Predatory wild animals, like the “roaring lion and charging bear” in Proverbs 28:15, are a common way to convey tyrrany in both biblical and Greek literature; see, e.g., Ezekiel 22, where people in power who commit a litany of crimes that threaten the social fabric are compared to a lion tearing its prey, and Plato, Republic 566a, where the tyrant is likened to a wolf. ↩︎
  27. The link with ancient Near Eastern kingship ideology is noted by Roland E. Murphy, Proverbs, Word Biblical Commentary 22 (Thomas Nelson, 1998), 221. ↩︎
  28. Fox, Proverbs 10–31, 814–15. For the idea that this is a royal proverb, see, e.g., Van Leeuwen, Context and Meaning, 137–40. Some object to the royal character of the collection because some of the sayings seem to offer a less than rosy depiction of the king; see, e.g., Claus Westermann, Roots of Wisdom: The Oldest Proverbs of Israel and Other Peoples, trans. J. Daryl Charles (Westminster John Knox, 1995), 33–34, who highlights Proverbs 28:15–16; 29:4, 12. This fails to account for the elevated depiction of the king in 25:2–7, as well as the fact that even negative examples highlight the ideal behavior of a king by implication (and that this kind of pedagogical strategy is attested elsewhere in Proverbs). ↩︎